Medical Economics Logo
  • Physicians Money Digest

  • Physicians Financial News

  • Physicians Practice

  • Chief Healthcare Executive

  • Patient Care Online

All NewsCareersLegalMoneyOpinionPhysicians Financial NewsPractice ManagementTechnology
Around the PracticeBetween The LinesClinical ConsultExpert InterviewsMedical Economics PulseMedical World NewsOff The Charts PodcastsPhysician ReportPrimaryViewSlideshows
Academy
Conference CoverageConference Listing
Medical EconomicsPatient Care SupplementSponsored ContentSponsored ResourcesSupplements And Featured Publications
CME/CEJob BoardSubscribe
Financial Advisor Guide
CareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareers
LegalLegalLegalLegalLegal
Medical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & Technology
Opinion
Physician's Money DigestPhysician's Money DigestPhysician's Money DigestPhysician's Money Digest
PolicyPolicyPolicyPolicyPolicyPolicy
Practice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice Finance
Practice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice Management
Practice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice Technology
Screening
Special ReportsSpecial ReportsSpecial Reports
Spotlight -
  • The benefits of a physician MBA program
  • Concierge Medicine 2.0 by Castle Connolly Private Health Partners
  • Physician Bootcamp
  • Physician Report
CareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareers
LegalLegalLegalLegalLegal
Medical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & Technology
Opinion
Physician's Money DigestPhysician's Money DigestPhysician's Money DigestPhysician's Money Digest
PolicyPolicyPolicyPolicyPolicyPolicy
Practice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice Finance
Practice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice Management
Practice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice Technology
Screening
Special ReportsSpecial ReportsSpecial Reports
    • Academy
    • CME/CE
    • Job Board
    • Subscribe
Advertisement

Article

February 20, 2009

Medicine vs. religion: Your legal obligations

Author(s):

Steven I. Kern, JD

What is your obligation when confronted with parents who are unwilling to accept medical advice in the best interest of their child because of their religious convictions?

Key Points

The January death of John Travolta's 16-year-old son raises significant questions for physicians faced with families who refuse necessary medical treatment for their children.

Reports-albeit denied by the family-suggest that the Travoltas refused to accept a diagnosis of autism for their child because their religion, Scientology, does not recognize autism as a medical condition. As a result, according to the same reports (again, denied), the Travoltas may not have accepted the medical treatment necessary to protect their child's life.

For a physician who might face a similar scenario, the question is: What is your obligation when confronted with parents who are unwilling to accept medical advice in the best interest of their child because of their religious convictions?

A more difficult case arises when the need for treatment is not so clear. What is the physician's obligation when death or serious injury cannot be predicted, but one course of treatment simply provides a statistically better likelihood of success than another treatment-or no treatment whatsoever? In these cases, it is hard to argue that a parent's decision to decline one course of treatment in favor of another (or none) constitutes abuse or neglect. After all, physicians don't ordinarily substitute their own opinion for that of the parents.

Where multiple recognized treatment options exist, the physician is best served by carefully explaining the risks and benefits of each, scrupulously documenting the advice, and allowing the family to make the decision. Once the decision is made, be sure to have the family provide written informed consent that details the advice provided.

However, where treatment options are limited, and the consequences of avoiding them may be grave, the prudent approach would be to obtain another opinion. A second opinion, agreeing that the decision should be left to the family, would certainly provide some cover.

If, however, the second opinion believes that the recommended treatment is mandatory, then few options remain. One is for the physician to ask the hospital to convene its ethics committee to provide guidance, and then follow that advice.

Alternatively, if the hospital is unwilling to become involved-and it may well seek to avoid getting involved-reporting the case to the appropriate state authorities may prove to be the most prudent course.

One final caveat: In cases where the minor's age or the nature of the condition being treated could fall under a state's laws governing medical decision-making by "emancipated minors" or "mature minors," a physician should consider the maturity of the patient and, where appropriate, include the minor in the discussion and decision-making process.

The author is a health law attorney with Kern Augustine Conroy & Schoppmann in Bridgewater, New Jersey; Lake Success, New York; and Philadelphia. He can be reached at [email protected]
. Malpractice Consult deals with questions on common professional liability issues. Unfortunately, we cannot offer specific legal advice. If you have a general question or a topic you'd like to see covered here, please send it to [email protected]
.

Newsletter

Stay informed and empowered with Medical Economics enewsletter, delivering expert insights, financial strategies, practice management tips and technology trends — tailored for today’s physicians.

Subscribe Now!
Related Videos
The new standard for medical malpractice: A conversation with Daniel G. Aaron, M.D., J.D.
The new standard for medical malpractice: What to watch for
The new standard for medical malpractice: A step toward ending defensive medicine?
The new standard for medical malpractice: Can doctors be liable for doing what everyone else does?
The new standard for medical malpractice: What makes a clinical guideline legally defensible?
The new standard for medical malpractice: What it means for day-to-day practice
The new standard for medical malpractice: What changed?
The new standard for medical malpractice: Why the law just changed
ACP policy update 2025: A conversation with Brian E. Outland, PhD
ACP policy update 2025 interview
Related Content
Advertisement
Protect your assets with solid strategies: ©kamon saejueng - stock.adobe.com
July 18th 2025

Asset protection strategies for primary care physicians: Safeguarding your future

Off the Chart: A Business of Medicine Podcast - Ep. 73: Why physicians are suing RFK Jr., with attorney Richard H. Hughes IV, J.D., M.P.H.
July 14th 2025

Ep. 73: Why physicians are suing RFK Jr., with attorney Richard H. Hughes IV, J.D., M.P.H.

DOJ drops charges against Utah physician accused in COVID-19 fraud scheme © Tada Images - stock.adobe.com
July 14th 2025

DOJ drops charges against Utah physician accused in COVID-19 fraud scheme

Off the Chart: A Business of Medicine Podcast - Ep. 68: Hidden risks of prescribing GLP-1 drugs with Ericka L. Adler, J.D., of Roetzel & Andress
June 9th 2025

Ep. 68: Hidden risks of prescribing GLP-1 drugs with Ericka L. Adler, J.D., of Roetzel & Andress

Biggest health care fraud crackdown in U.S. history targets $14.6 billion in alleged scams © Heidi - stock.adobe.com
June 30th 2025

Biggest health care fraud crackdown in U.S. history targets $14.6B in alleged scams

Andrea Greco, SVP of healthcare safety at CENTEGIX
June 26th 2025

Safety starts with trust: Reassessing real-time location systems in health care

Related Content
Advertisement
Protect your assets with solid strategies: ©kamon saejueng - stock.adobe.com
July 18th 2025

Asset protection strategies for primary care physicians: Safeguarding your future

Off the Chart: A Business of Medicine Podcast - Ep. 73: Why physicians are suing RFK Jr., with attorney Richard H. Hughes IV, J.D., M.P.H.
July 14th 2025

Ep. 73: Why physicians are suing RFK Jr., with attorney Richard H. Hughes IV, J.D., M.P.H.

DOJ drops charges against Utah physician accused in COVID-19 fraud scheme © Tada Images - stock.adobe.com
July 14th 2025

DOJ drops charges against Utah physician accused in COVID-19 fraud scheme

Off the Chart: A Business of Medicine Podcast - Ep. 68: Hidden risks of prescribing GLP-1 drugs with Ericka L. Adler, J.D., of Roetzel & Andress
June 9th 2025

Ep. 68: Hidden risks of prescribing GLP-1 drugs with Ericka L. Adler, J.D., of Roetzel & Andress

Biggest health care fraud crackdown in U.S. history targets $14.6 billion in alleged scams © Heidi - stock.adobe.com
June 30th 2025

Biggest health care fraud crackdown in U.S. history targets $14.6B in alleged scams

Andrea Greco, SVP of healthcare safety at CENTEGIX
June 26th 2025

Safety starts with trust: Reassessing real-time location systems in health care

About
Advertise
Contact Us
Editorial Staff
Job Board
Terms and Conditions
Contributor Guidelines
Privacy Policy
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Contact Info

2 Commerce Drive
Cranbury, NJ 08512

609-716-7777

© 2025 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.